Getting arrested for public intoxication after attending a Stillwater watch party can feel like a nightmare. Whether it’s a Saturday football game or a community gathering, public intoxication is one of the most common reasons for arrests in the area. The good news is that a public intoxication charge doesn’t necessarily mean you’re guilty. There are several common defenses that can potentially hold up in court, and understanding them can make all the difference. In this post, we’ll discuss these defenses in-depth, explaining how each one works and why it could help your case.
The Basics of Public Intoxication in Stillwater 
Stillwater, Oklahoma, like many cities across the state, enforces laws against public intoxication. Public intoxication generally occurs when an individual is visibly impaired by alcohol or drugs in a public space to such an extent that it creates a potential risk to themselves or others. In Stillwater, this often occurs during events like watch parties where crowds gather to celebrate sports or other community activities.
However, it’s important to know that being arrested for public intoxication doesn’t automatically equate to a conviction. Law enforcement must prove that you were, in fact, intoxicated to the extent that it was dangerous or disruptive. The burden of proof lies with the prosecution, and there are several defenses available to challenge these charges.
Public intoxication laws aim to maintain public safety but also to ensure that individuals’ rights are protected. Let’s dive into the most common defenses that may hold up in Stillwater’s local courts.
1. Lack of Evidence of Intoxication
One of the most common defenses against public intoxication charges is the lack of evidence proving that you were actually intoxicated. While a police officer may believe someone is drunk, simply looking or smelling like you’ve been drinking is not enough to justify an arrest. The law requires concrete proof that the individual is indeed impaired.
James V. Murray
Attorney with Over 40 Years Experience
The Importance of Field Sobriety Tests
In many public intoxication cases, officers rely on field sobriety tests (FSTs) or breathalyzer tests to establish that an individual is under the influence. However, FSTs are not always reliable. Many factors can interfere with the accuracy of a sobriety test, including fatigue, medical conditions, or even the environment in which the test is performed.
For example, an individual who is nervous or has a medical condition that affects coordination might fail a sobriety test even though they aren’t intoxicated. Additionally, breathalyzer devices can sometimes malfunction or provide false results. If these tests are improperly administered or their reliability is questioned, the evidence against you may be insufficient to prove intoxication.
The Role of Eyewitness Testimony
If no physical test of intoxication was performed, the prosecution will rely on witness testimony. This could be from the arresting officer or bystanders who observed your behavior. However, eyewitness testimony is subjective and can be influenced by many factors, such as the officer’s state of mind or the way the crowd perceived your behavior. If there’s any doubt about the accuracy of the witnesses’ accounts, your attorney can challenge the evidence, making it harder for the prosecution to prove that you were intoxicated.
2. Improper Police Procedure
Another valid defense for public intoxication charges in Stillwater is improper police procedure during the arrest. If an officer violates your rights, it could make the case against you invalid. A few examples of improper procedure include:
- Unlawful Detention: If the officer did not have a valid reason to stop or detain you, any evidence they gathered may be considered inadmissible.
- Failure to Read Miranda Rights: If you were not informed of your right to remain silent or to have an attorney present before questioning, any statements you made during the arrest may be thrown out.
- Violation of Search Protocols: Police must follow strict protocols during the arrest process. If they search you or your belongings without probable cause or a warrant, that could result in a dismissal of the evidence they gathered.
Any breach of procedure can create significant doubt about the integrity of the arrest, and your attorney can use these violations as grounds for a case dismissal or reduction in charges.
Mr. Murray and his team were very professional and helpful throughout this process. As my case was very unique, I knew I was going to need a very specific and special team to help me through this. My wife and I prayed about it and God led us to Murray Law Firm. During the first consultation I requested he pray with me about it and he was quick to agree and that is when I knew we had made the right decision. They went above and beyond our expectations and won the case. I would highly recommend this firm.”
- Roger Buchanan
The Murray Law Firm worked wonders for me and my needs. James Murray along with his staff are so helpful, understanding, and answered all my questions and concerns. James was able to work his magic and get things done in such a timely manner. James even made his self available by phone after hours when I was in such need. He put not only mine but my whole families worries and concerns at ease. Would highly recommend James Murray to anyone searching for a very good attorney!"
- Tiara Rich
Jamie is personal yet professional. He can put you at ease and make you feel safe and secure. He will be at your side through this most difficult time in your life and will keep you informed about what is going on in your case and what you can expect. His staff is always ready and willing to do everything the can to help you. Highly recommended."
- Alicia Mayfield
3. Mistaken Identity
In large crowds, like those typically seen at watch parties in Stillwater, mistaken identity is a plausible defense. Officers may arrest someone simply because they appear to be intoxicated, but without clearly identifying the individual as the one engaging in disruptive behavior.
Crowded Events and False Impressions
At a crowded sports bar or public watch event, it’s easy for officers to misidentify a person as intoxicated simply because they are near others who are visibly impaired. The environment may include loud noises, celebrations, and other factors that could skew an officer’s judgment. If there’s a chance you were mistaken for someone else, your lawyer can argue that the arrest was based on a false impression rather than factual evidence.
4. Medical or Mental Health Conditions
Certain medical or mental health conditions can cause symptoms that mimic the signs of intoxication. If you have a medical condition or mental health issue that affects your coordination, speech, or behavior, you may appear intoxicated even when you’re not. Some examples of conditions that could mimic intoxication include:
- Diabetes: Low blood sugar or other symptoms of diabetes can cause shakiness, confusion, or slurred speech.
- Neurological Conditions: Disorders like Parkinson’s disease, stroke, or certain types of seizures can cause unsteady movement or impaired coordination.
- Mental Health Disorders: Conditions like anxiety or panic attacks can cause physical symptoms such as unsteady walking, sweating, or difficulty speaking.
If you were diagnosed with a medical or mental health condition, or if your behavior was caused by such a condition, your attorney can present this as part of your defense. You may not have been intoxicated, but your condition led others to misinterpret your actions.
Criminal Defense Case Results
5. Private Property Exception
In Stillwater, there may be instances where someone is arrested for public intoxication while on private property. Public intoxication laws generally apply to public spaces—places that are open to the general public. If you were on private property at the time of your arrest, such as inside a private residence, your behavior may not be subject to public intoxication laws.
The Role of Private Property in Public Intoxication Defense
For example, if you were arrested after leaving a private party at someone’s home and still on the property, it could be argued that the arrest was unjustified. However, if you were on public property—such as a sidewalk or parking lot adjacent to the private property—this defense would not apply.
The nuances of whether you were in a private or public place can influence the success of this defense, and an experienced attorney can help evaluate the circumstances of your arrest.
6. Voluntary Intoxication as a Defense
In certain criminal cases, voluntary intoxication might be considered a defense to criminal behavior, but not always for public intoxication cases. Public intoxication laws are usually strict and don’t allow for the defense of voluntary intoxication.
However, in more serious cases, such as those involving assaults or disturbances, an individual may claim they didn’t intend to commit the offense because they were intoxicated. The defense would argue that the individual was not in control of their actions. But in most public intoxication cases, this argument does not hold up. Instead, the focus is typically on whether you were visibly impaired in a public setting.
Facing a public intoxication charge after attending a Stillwater watch party doesn’t automatically mean a conviction. There are numerous defenses available that can protect your rights and potentially reduce or dismiss the charges against you. Whether it’s proving a lack of evidence of intoxication, challenging improper police procedure, or presenting a case of mistaken identity, understanding these defenses can make all the difference.
If you or someone you know has been arrested for public intoxication in Stillwater, don’t hesitate to contact Murray Law Firm for a free consultation. Our experienced criminal defense attorneys can help you explore your options and fight for the best possible outcome in your case.